What the painters were given

Trees: how they are built

notes/research/trees.md · 105 lines · Research

Given to 6 painters:

Trees: how they are built

A sourced note on how trees grow, branch and taper. Every claim carries a source key in brackets; the sources are listed at the end. "General knowledge" marks statements not tied to a source; "My inference" marks conclusions drawn from sourced facts.

In short

  1. A tree is a branching system that grows at its tips and thickens everywhere. Strong side branches arise mostly near the top of each year's shoot (acrotony). Upright axes build the frame; side axes spread sideways. When a tip dies, the one or more side shoots below it take over, so the axis forks or zigzags [BC pp.381–387].
  2. Diameter is conserved across forks, roughly. The cross-section below a fork about equals the sum of the cross-sections above it (the branch-area rule). The measured exponent is 1.8–2.3 instead of exactly 2 [ELOY p.1; MT p.1]. Every twig is the thin end of a continuous path to the roots [LEH].
  3. A side branch is thickest where it leaves its parent. It is set into the trunk as a sleeve: the branch's own wood turns down and wraps its base as a collar, and trunk wood wraps over that collar every year [SHIGO]. A swelling underneath (the branch collar) and usually a raised ridge of bark on top (the branch bark ridge) mark the junction [USDA p.10].
  4. Healthy crowns end in a network of long shoots; stressed ones don't. Roloff's four vitality stages run from a net of long shoots at the crown edge (healthy) to spiky "bottle-brush" tips, then bushy chains of short shoots, then dieback and a shrinking crown [ROL17]. He rates each stage against the tree's age, and asks when the short-shoot stage is simply normal in old oaks [ROL17].
  5. Old trees shrink downward rather than simply dying. An ancient oak loses its upper crown and keeps a live, often dense lower crown. It becomes "stag-headed," with dead limbs standing above the living foliage, and usually hollow [ATF; HTC; WT].

Terms used below. Acrotony: side branches strongest near the tip of the parent shoot. Orthotropic/plagiotropic: growing upright/growing sideways. Long shoot/short shoot: a year's extension that is long and carries branches versus a stubby one. Epicormic shoot: a shoot from a dormant bud on an old trunk or limb (German Wasserreiser). Reiteration: the tree repeating its own basic architecture as a new sub-crown [BC pp.390–391]. Retrenchment: natural shrinking of an old crown [ATF]. Stag-headed: dead top limbs standing above a live lower crown [HTC]. Cladoptosis: a tree's regular shedding of twigs at an abscission layer [WP-CLAD]. Sapwood/heartwood: conducting outer wood/non-conducting inner wood.

1. How a tree is built

2. How branches taper and join

3. The species

3.1 Oak (Quercus robur, pedunculate; Q. petraea, sessile)

3.2 Beech (Fagus sylvatica)

3.3 Birch (Betula pendula, silver; B. pubescens, downy)

3.4 Lime (Tilia cordata, small-leaved; T. platyphyllos, large-leaved)

3.5 Willow (white willow, Salix alba; other tree willows)

3.6 Alder (Alnus glutinosa, black alder)

3.7 Norway spruce (Picea abies)

3.8 Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris)

Sources

Source