What the painters were given

Trees in Friedrich's world: how they are built and how he used them

notes/research/trees.md · 220 lines · Research

Given to 6 painters:

Trees in Friedrich's world: how they are built and how he used them

Sourced note for painters who work from knowledge, not pictures. Companion to friedrich_materials.md (materials) and friedrich_process.md (process). Every claim carries a source key in brackets; full URLs are in "Sources" at the end. "General knowledge" marks botanical statements I could not tie to a source I read. "My inference" marks conclusions I drew from sourced facts. "Unverified" marks claims I saw only secondhand. Rule kept throughout: no picture of his was looked at; descriptions of his works come from museum, catalog and scholarly text only.

Bottom line

  1. A tree is a branching system that grows at its tips and thickens everywhere. Strong side branches arise mostly near the top of each year's shoot (acrotony). Upright axes build the frame; side axes spread sideways. When a tip dies, the one or more side shoots below it take over, so the axis forks or zigzags [BC pp.381–387].
  2. Diameter is conserved across forks, roughly. The cross-section below a fork about equals the sum of the cross-sections above it (Leonardo's rule). The measured exponent is 1.8–2.3 instead of exactly 2 [ELOY p.1; MT p.1]. Every twig is the thin end of a continuous path to the roots [LEH].
  3. A side branch is thickest where it leaves its parent. It is set into the trunk as a sleeve: the branch's own wood turns down and wraps its base as a collar, and trunk wood wraps over that collar every year [SHIGO]. A swelling underneath (the branch collar) and usually a raised ridge of bark on top (the branch bark ridge) mark the junction [USDA p.10].
  4. Healthy crowns end in a network of long shoots; stressed ones don't. Roloff's four vitality stages run from a net of long shoots at the crown edge (healthy) to spiky "bottle-brush" tips, then bushy chains of short shoots, then dieback and a shrinking crown [ROL17]. He rates each stage against the tree's age, and asks when the short-shoot stage is simply normal in old oaks [ROL17].
  5. Old trees shrink downward rather than simply dying. An ancient oak loses its upper crown and keeps a live, often dense lower crown. It becomes "stag-headed," with dead limbs standing above the living foliage, and usually hollow [ATF; HTC; WT].
  6. A pollard willow is a thick trunk cut at 2–4 m with a swollen knuckle (the "head") on top. Many rods sprout from just below the old cut [DVL]. On a vigorous tree they can grow 1.5–2.5 m in a year [LOGAN]. Rods were harvested every one to ten years, depending on use. Pollards left uncut too long split apart under their heavy limbs [DVL; BL].
  7. Snow sticks best near 0 °C. Adhesion rises as the air warms toward freezing, and cold dry snow is shaken off bare trees [MIL64 pp.5–6]. Snow lies in bands on smooth bark and in heaps on rough bark [MIL64 p.6]. It slides off sloping or bent supports and lets go first where it touches the branch [MIL66]. Rime (Raueis) grows into the wind; hoarfrost (Raureif) is fragile needles formed in calm, humid cold [DWD].
  8. Friedrich built his trees from dated pencil studies of individual trees, reused for decades. Roughly 400 of about 1300 drawings put trees at the center, mostly oaks and spruces [ROL]. One 1809 oak study served paintings from 1811 to about 1835 [MET PDF p.37]. He drew with a horizon line marked even on the lower trunk and kept that viewpoint in the painting [BUSCH-V pp.77–78].
  9. Pollard willows: yes, in at least one painting; he also made several willow studies. The Hut in the Snow (1827) shows willows that one scholar calls "pollard willows" [UCL p.26]. The museum text describes their "vigorous young shoots" [CDF-HÜT]. Willow studies are dated 1799, 1808, 1809 and 1812. One tree biologist reports that pictures of lopped trees are nearly absent from his work [ROL]. Details in §5.6.

Terms used below. Acrotony: side branches strongest near the tip of the parent shoot. Orthotropic/plagiotropic: growing upright/growing sideways. Long shoot/short shoot: a year's extension that is long and carries branches versus a stubby one. Epicormic shoot: a shoot from a dormant bud on an old trunk or limb (German Wasserreiser). Reiteration: the tree repeating its own basic architecture as a new sub-crown [BC pp.390–391]. Retrenchment: natural shrinking of an old crown [ATF]. Stag-headed: dead top limbs standing above a live lower crown [HTC]. Pollard: tree cut back repeatedly at head height. Bolling/head: the permanent trunk and knuckle of a pollard. Rods: the shoots from the head. Cladoptosis: a tree's regular shedding of twigs at an abscission layer [WP-CLAD]. Sapwood/heartwood: conducting outer wood/non-conducting inner wood. Raureif/Raueis: hoarfrost/rime.

1. How a tree is built

2. How branches taper and join

3. The species

3.1 Oak (Quercus robur, pedunculate; Q. petraea, sessile)

3.2 Beech (Fagus sylvatica)

3.3 Birch (Betula pendula, silver; B. pubescens, downy)

3.4 Lime (Tilia cordata, small-leaved; T. platyphyllos, large-leaved)

3.5 Willow (white willow, Salix alba; other tree willows) and the pollard

3.6 Alder (Alnus glutinosa, black alder)

3.7 Norway spruce (Picea abies)

3.8 Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris)

4. Snow and hoarfrost on bare trees

5. How Friedrich studied and used trees

5.1 How much, and which trees

5.2 How he drew trees outdoors

5.3 Studies reused in paintings (dates from text sources)

Study Used in Source
Oak, c.1804 (Karlsruhe sketchbook) Left oak of Dolmen in the Snow (1807) [WP-HÜN]
Oak, 1804; oak, 5 May 1809 First oak right and second oak left of the ruin, Abbey in the Oakwood (1809–10). Most of its oaks come from studies made at Neubrandenburg in 1809 [WP-ABT]
Old Oak with Stork's Nest, 23 May 1806 Left oak of the sepia Dolmen by the Sea (1807); central oak of The Solitary Tree (1822), 15 years later [CDF-STORCH; WP-EIN]
Study of vine leaves and beeches, 13/14 June 1809; Group of Large Oaks, 16 June 1809; tree studies, 9/12 June 1809 Single oak left (with added twigs), group of four and two oaks right, The Solitary Tree [WP-EIN]
Two Tree Studies, Neubrandenburg, 25/26 April 1809 ("Eiche") Two oaks among stumps in Winter Landscape (Schwerin, 1811). The large oak in all three Two Men/Man and Woman Contemplating the Moon (hollowed crooked trunk from the lower study, zigzag branch from the upper, partly leafy study). Ruins in Twilight (1831) and Forest, Late Autumn (c.1835): "over a period of more than twenty years" [MET PDF p.37]
Bare oak, 3 May 1809 The Tree of Crows (c.1822): branches added at left and others lengthened to stretch across the picture [WP-CROW; MET PDF p.16]
Detailed pencil study Central tree group of Winter Landscape (London, 1811) [NG p.49]
Spruces drawn 1807; tallest tree drawn 1804 The Cross in the Mountains: when painting it in oil he replaced most trees of the sepia. The revised spruces are slimmer; only the 1804 tree kept its place [BIRK p.238]
Tree study, 23 October 1801 (Oslo) Leftmost tree of a late transparency, reused "after more than thirty years" [MET PDF p.45]

The Solitary Tree's oak is described as a composite of studies made between 1806 and 1810 [CDF-EIN; MET PDF p.40]. The bare oak in winter recurs in Dolmen in the Snow (1807), Winter (1808, burned 1931), Abbey in the Oakwood, Monastery Graveyard in the Snow (1819, lost) and Oak in the Snow (Cologne, 1827). Oak Tree in Snow (Berlin, 1829) is the most concentrated version [CDF-EICH]. For Abbey he wrote in 1809: "the oaks stretch their arms upward out of the fog, while below they have already quite vanished" [WP-ABT, quoting the letters].

5.4 Which paintings have which trees (from text)

5.5 How he painted them, according to conservators and scholars

5.6 Did he paint pollard willows?

Yes, in at least one painting that the sources name, and he studied willows repeatedly. The motif is rare in his work.

Gaps

Sources

Tree architecture and biology

Species (forestry references)

Pollards

Snow and frost

Friedrich

Source