The painter's sketchbook
Read this before you paint at the easel (crates/easel/README.md). It holds craft
(techniques with the numbers that worked, and the mistakes that cost painters the most
time), never finished pictures to copy. Credits in brackets: [r2 winter] is round 2 (Rust,
older API, notes/amnesia2/, only its lessons that translate to the easel), [r3 ...]
round 3 (notes/amnesia3/), [r4 ...] round 4 with the drawing tools (easel4_green,
easel4_near). Add what you learn in the same form: what to do, the recipe, what goes
wrong.
These are the best techniques so far, not the best possible. Every recipe is a floor to beat. Each section names its ceiling: where the best recipe still reads as schematic or digital. If a passage of yours still reads digital, don't settle for the recipe: try something new, and if the critic scores it better, replace the entry (don't keep both). Pitfalls stay: they only prevent bad results.
Hierarchical detail, not maximal subtraction (Alice, Round 6).
Economy doesn't mean less detail everywhere; it means detail placed where
the eye goes and massed where it doesn't. Big shapes and value families
first, then a middle scale of irregular groups, then a few selected
particulars. The Round 6 lab (notes/lab/, notes/round6.md) found both
failures: too little (foliage as blobs or domes, a bare tree's twigs as a
tone that read as fur) lost to the old detailed recipes, and too much (an
even carpet of 40,000 touches, a starburst at every twig tip) read as
procedural noise. What won kept the middle scale: bare tree C (fewer,
varied, tapered twigs, all connected), water B, sky B, rock B.
1. Working order and time
- Order. Draw; the sky thin; the distance far to near; the ground as tone; the motifs; small particulars last with pointed brushes; grass last of all in fine upturning strokes over finished ground or snow.
- Working in sittings (hand time) [r6 time]. Principle: a stroke costs the time a
hand takes to make it, and a painter works in sittings of a few hours with the paint
setting between them. Then what is wet when a passage meets its neighbor follows from
the work, not from a rule.
canvas{..., hand=true},sitting{hours=3},rest(16),timesheet(),look --mode wet(crates/easel/README.md, notes/time.md). What follows from it:- In one sitting the paint under a later passage is still open and comes up into it.
Lay each passage only where it shows, a little (about 10 units) past where its
neighbor will meet it. A ridge painted to the bottom of the canvas and then a dark
knoll over it in the same sitting came out cobbled with churned-up light paint. Laid
only where it shows, the knoll stayed solid, with a soft shoulder against the ridge,
and the ridge took 42 minutes of hand time instead of 90
(
notes/time/example_three_ways.jpg). - The time of an edge decides its character: painted into open paint it is lost (a
hill's top drags the sky down), after lunch (
rest(4)) it drags less, and the next day (rest(16)) it is crisp likedry()(notes/time/edge_timing.jpg). Put the rest where you want a found edge. - Read the timesheet as the price of detail: the fir wood in
l5_nearis 53 hours of hand time (211,000 hatched strokes), the whole sky 32 minutes. - Ceiling: the times are estimates (Fitts and the steering law are sourced; the
palette trips, which are most of the time, are guesses), a pass ages in 15-minute
slices from the top down rather than along a painter's path, and how open paint
looks where two passages meet (a pale, streaky drag band) is still unresolved. The
dry()rule below stands until the wet-on-wet work decides it.
- In one sitting the paint under a later passage is still open and comes up into it.
Lay each passage only where it shows, a little (about 10 units) past where its
neighbor will meet it. A ridge painted to the bottom of the canvas and then a dark
knoll over it in the same sitting came out cobbled with churned-up light paint. Laid
only where it shows, the knoll stayed solid, with a soft shoulder against the ridge,
and the ridge took 42 minutes of hand time instead of 90
(
dry()before any passage that goes over earlier work.wait(24*60)is often not enough. A thick body floor (coverage 4.5) was still "open" after a day, and the rock laid over it went semi-transparent [r3 near]. Snow over a day-old near-black wood smeared into a gray fog band [r4 near]. A river over wet valley paint plowed through to the red ground [r4 green]. If you aren't sure,print(drying(x, y))at the spot first.- Fine lines only on dry paint. Cracks drawn into open paint come out dashed like stitching [r3 near]. Stones painted 4 h after the grass came out green-streaked; a day's wait fixed it [r3 green].
- Waits that worked. Sky, then
wait(24*60)and the second sky layer or stipple [r3 green, r3 near].wait(180)was enough for a sky stipple over a thin (medium 0.3) lay-in [r3 free].wait(120)towait(3*60)before hatching a wood or a tree over a fresh hill worked [r4 green]. - Glaze timing.
glaze()waits until everything under it is touch-dry (8 to 29 days of clock each) [r4 green], so never put one inside a wet-into-wet sequence. A veil that doesn't wait:work(m, {hand="glaze", medium=0.8, color_over={shift={...}}}). - Finish old. The standard last chunk is
wait(24*60); varnish{...}; cracks{}; relief(): a Friedrich is two centuries old and cracked, and Alice wants the craquelure as part of the final look (Round 6). Judge glitches with and without it: cracks are marks too. - Retouch before the varnish. Keep
wait(24*60); varnish{...}; cracks{}; relief()as the last chunk and fix things witheasel edit N --insertbefore it: seconds, not a replay [r4 near, r4 green]. Since round 6 the varnish (and anyglaze()) coats every stroke ridge and pools only a little in the hollows, the same at 1000 and 3200: no need to thincoatsto 0.12 against brown worm lines at paint edges (notes/varnish.md) [r6 varnish]. - Keep
relief()at its default. The Friedrich default is now(0.06, 0.006), the Alice's pick from the Round 6 A/B (notes/round6/relief/): the old 0.2 embossed every stroke into creases ("grooves") and raised outlines around sky holes.relief(0.6)turned a sky into swirling impasto [r3 free]. Relief lighting can't fix pale rims, halos or cut-out edges: those are in the paint.
2. Skies and air
Ceiling: skies read as smooth, even gradients ("too neat") and impasto cumulus reads lumpy; nobody has yet painted a Friedrich sky with real structure (banks, breaks, an uneven glow) that also reads as paint.
- The sky is two thin layers, the second stippled over the first once it's set. This
is the move that most often made a sky read as Friedrich's rather than as scrubbed paint
[r3 free, r3 near, r3 green, r2 all].
With a clouds object, a second broad pass works too:skypal = pal:only{"lead white","pale smalt","cobalt blue","yellow ochre","raw umber","red earth"} work(skym, {hand="broad", color=sky, angle=0, coverage=4.2, medium=0.3, pal=skypal}) blend(skym, {angle=0}) -- next chunk wait(24*60) stipple(skym, {width=2.6, color=sky, coverage=2.6, pressure={0.4, 0.8}, dips={18, 0.35, 0.7}, medium=0.55})wait(24*60), thenwork(..., {hand="broad", color=cl, coverage=3.5, medium=0.35, aim=1.6})andblend[r3 green]. - Restrict the sky palette. Leave out the greens. Add chrome yellow and vermilion only for a warm glow [r3 free]. A full palette flecks skies and ranges orange where the mix jitters [r2 mountains].
- Lay the first sky a shade duller than the target; the stipple lifts it [r2 winter, r2 coast].
- A stipple lighter than the field reads as salt where it thins. Lift only about 0.006 to 0.028 in OKLab L above the field and keep coverage at 0.9 or more everywhere [r2 coast].
- Never stipple a pale veil over a dark passage. Every dot stands alone (static,
"frogspawn" at 3200). Mist over dark hills is a brushed veil instead:
hand="broad", medium 0.6, density throughload_at, then a clippedblend. Keep stipple for the sky and already-light fog [r2 mountains]. - Clouds. Light on the lit tops a day later:
hand="scumble", warm white,coverage=2.2,medium=0.35,hug=false, throughcl:mask{alpha={0.45,0.85}, lit={0.5,0.9}}:blur(3). Darken the bellies withhand="glaze",medium=0.8,color_over={shift={-0.05, 0, -0.012}}through a:blur(4)shade mask. Then blend the grown cloud mask. Astippleon cloud edges gave white speckle, and a hard-maskedglaze()gave gray slabs [r4 green]. - An afterglow that
w:skygot wrong (it read as noon): your own gradient with a Gaussianmath.exp(-((x - SUNX)/520)^2)added to its t [r3 free]. - Haze at the foot of a range: a graded
glaze(hazem, {coats=0.55, pigment="semi"})and then a fine, low-contrast stipple (width=1.5,aim=false,medium=0.6,fade=1). A coarse stipple there read as frost [r3 green]. - Moon. The crescent is a mask (disc minus an offset disc) filled with short touches clipped to it, so the horns come to points. A dragged arc gives a blunt banana. A glow is stippled, not glazed [r2 winter, r2 mountains].
3. Water
- Calm sea = the mirrored sky, darkened toward you. Color field: `refl = skycol(x, HZ
- d*2.2 - 10)
(d = y - HZ), mixed into a dark that deepens over 120 units, plus a stretched noise (stretch={0, 30}`) for faint current lines [r3 free].
- d*2.2 - 10)
- Smooth a blotchy sea the same way as a sky: stipple a veil of its own gradient
(
width=2.2,coverage=2.6,medium=0.5), then while wetblend(veil, {angle=0, angle_jitter=0.003, length={80, 200}, coverage=2})[r3 free]. - Glints after
wait(240): horizontal rigger (0.9) strokes, pale ones mixed toward the mirrored sky and darker ones in the troughs (round 1.6), spaced closer near the horizon (y += 1.2 + d*0.055 + rand(0, 1)), longer and more numerous toward you, gathered under the glow [r3 free]. - No flat brush in
broadover water: brick marks, and it dragged wet paint from neighbors [r3 free]. Calm water wants whole level strokes, nobrokenortail, over an underpainting in its own tones (a flat one showed through where strokes ran dry) [r2 coast]. - A river:
w:ribbon(pts, width_m)in meters, laid after the valley has set. Author canvas points and convert each withw:to_ground(keep{p[1], p[3]}) so it narrows by itself [r4 green].
4. Distance and ranges
Ceiling: ranges still read as parallel bands or boxy crests; far woods as hedges of repeated round blobs.
w:rangescan come out boxy (crenellated crests) [r3 green]. Hand crests are reliable: noise plus a Gaussian dome or two, e.g.HZ - 16 - 10*n:at01(x,0) - 44*math.exp(-((x-770)/105)^2), masked withbelow(crest):roughen(0.8, 9), body strokes 25 to 70 long at a near-level angle, color from crest to foot [r3 green].- Stroke ends crenellate any hard crest. Cut the sky back over it: sample the sky 26
units above the crest, lay it over the edge with a slightly noisy line and blend. Fade
the cut-in in with
smoothstep, never stop it at a vertical seam (visible at 3200). Keep it away from wet motifs, which it smears along the horizon [r3 green]. - Each range a clear step darker and cooler than the one behind. In contre-jour, near forms go darker than far ones [r2 mountains].
- Fields in perspective: color the plain per point from ground coordinates.
worleycells in rotated meters (U/55, V/95) gave fields of the right size; 140 m cells were giant blotches. Try the scale witheasel tryand a probe first. Haze each field withmix(c, sk:airlight(x), w:aerial(Z)*0.95)[r4 green, r3 green]. - Hedgerows and groves: hatched (round 1.2 to 1.6, lengths 1.5 to 5) with turning
angles, sized by eye (by
w:heightat a high eye they were pillars). Rows of round crowns, identical field trees and thin ruled hedge masks read as stamps and lines: vary size, spacing (uneven), shape and shadow, and break hedges with noise [r3 green, r4 green].
5. Trees
Ceiling: oaks come out as umbrella/savanna crowns or "broccoli"; spruce tiers as regular chevrons; field trees as identical balls; wood interiors as flat black masses. No painter has yet drawn a tree with its structure, only built one from parameters.
Broadleaves from a drawing: tree_in{} and tree_group{} (THE TOOL TO USE for oak,
beech, lime, birch and willow; use it before tree{}/t:foliage{} or a hand-built crown).
Draw the crown as an outline{}, lopsided and lobed (a symmetric blob grows a
lollipop), and the trunk from the foot up. Then
t = tree_in{crown=o, trunk={{x,foot},...}, species="oak"|"beech"|"lime"|"birch"|"willow", season="summer"|"spring"|"autumn"|"late_autumn"|"winter", sun=WORLD, seed=} grows the limbs
from the trunk into your crown, with the crown's own gaps, leaf clumps on the twigs and hooked
touches on the clumps [trees_in study, paintings/lua/trees_in.lua]. Paint it in this order:
- Wood:
work(t:wood(3.5), {hand="body", tool="round 2", ...}). Put the lit flank only ont:wood(7), since a flank on thin limbs turns them into pale lines. Thent:paint_wood(brush("round", 2.4), {min=1.2, max=3.5})andbrush("rigger", 0.9), {max=1.2}. - The leaves' body:
work(t:leaves(), {hand="hatch", tool="round 1.6", hug=false, clip=...}), colored fromL = t:light():mix(mix("#222b1d", "#35412a", smoothstep(0.1, 0.45, v)), "#5c6a3a", smoothstep(0.5, 0.85, v)). A single body color gives one dark blob. - Sky into
t:gaps()before the touches, or the holes keep hard cut-out edges. - Touches,
b = brush("round", t.touch_w):lit={0, 0.4}#263020;lit={0.15, 0.4}, depth={0.25, 1}, share=0.5in a cool#4a5446(the front shade masses catch the sky);lit={0.4, 0.6}#46522e;lit={0.6, 0.78}#6f7c45;lit={0.78, 1}#98a060,every=6.
A bare tree: the same crown, trunk and seed with season="winter" grow the same wood (even
moved across the canvas). Principle: draw the structure, select the twigs, leave the sky. A
painter draws the big limbs whole and a few twigs with character, and leaves the rest out.
tree_in does the picking: detail= (default 0.35 bare) is the share of the fine wood drawn,
always with the wood it leaves from. An oak's wood is angular (straight runs, elbows at the
nodes, short stiff twigs; angular, on by default for oaks) [bare_trees study,
paintings/lua/bare_trees.lua, notes/oak.md]. Paint the wood thick to thin, each band with a
brush that can lay its widths:
t:wood(3.5) as body paint (lit flank on t:wood(7)), then
t:paint_wood(brush("round", 2.4), {min=1.2, max=3.5}), then
t:paint_wood(brush("rigger", 0.9), {min=0.5, max=1.2, every=2}) and
t:paint_wood(brush("rigger", 0.55), {max=0.5, pressure=0.04, every=2}), the fine wood a shade
lighter than the limbs. The bands are local widths, so nothing floats. A single rigger 0.55 for
everything under 1.2 paints it all one width (it lays 0.21 to 0.71): no taper at the forks.
Don't lay a tone for the undrawn twigs (t:twig_mass()): a blind panel of four critics called
it "steel wool", "fur" and "gray scribble cushions" and preferred the drawn twigs, and toned trees
look heavier and smeared.
Paint only share=0.4 of the dead leaves an oak keeps, or they read as burrs.
Ceiling: at 1000 px the drawn twigs are sub-pixel hairlines and read as faint lines; the
oak's crown is still a model's (limbs cross each other more than a real crown's do), and a few
sibling limbs run side by side like doubled lines.
Field trees: draw 2–3 different crowns (a broad low one, a tall narrow one) with short
trunks, then tree_group{crowns=, trunks=, species={...}, count=6, horizon=HZ, spread=0.8}.
Paint far to near with t.haze, and lay one g:shadow():blur(1.5) glaze at 0.25. Don't
roughen the shadow: it breaks into speckles.
Still weak [trees_in study]: sky holes have crisp torn-paper edges at 3200; a beech's
leader reads as a gray pole through its crown; a birch's white stem runs high into the crown.
Firs from a drawing: fir{} and fir_wood{} (use these before hand-building a spruce).
Draw the silhouette as an outline{} (apex, flanks, the crown's base) and
fir{envelope=o, foot={x, y}, habit="spire"|"old"|"young"|"storm", seed=} grows
a spruce into it: uneven whorls, gaps in runs, dead and broken lower boughs, tips
on your line. Paint it in this order [firs study, paintings/lua/firs.lua]:
work(f:needles(), {hand="hatch", tool="round 1.8", length={3, 7}, coverage=2.4, clip=f:needles(), angle=...}), dark#1c2621→#25302adown the tree. Use a continuous angle,1.57 + 0.5*clamp((ax - x)/12, -1, 1). An angle that flips at the stem leaves a pale seam down the tree at 3200.- Boughs with a rigger 1.2 (
f.boughs, dead ones#6a655d) andf:paint(brush("rigger", 0.6), {color="#77716a", kind="twig"}). Stroke the stem only belowf.crown_base - f.tier; a full-length stem stroke reads as a pale line. f:paint(brush("round", f.hatch), {color="#18211d", lit={0, 0.5}}), then#34402fforlit={0.5, 0.7}, then#667052with a brush 0.8x forlit={0.7, 1}, every=6. These are the short hatched strokes, hung from each bough, lit by the sun you passed (sun=).
Draw each envelope yourself: lopsided, a torn flank, a notch for a lost top. A
symmetric envelope still gives a Christmas tree. old at 400 units reads as
curtain branches hanging off a crooked stem, young as a dense cone to the snow.
A wood: wood = fir_wood{skyline=outline{pts=TOP, open=true, char="soft", lobe=14}, foot=516, depth=4, count=13}. Paint rows far to near. Row r's needles
are mix(dark, air, 0.62*wood:haze(r)) with air a shade darker than the low sky
(#a4a7a1); 0.95 went milky. Paint trunks with a rigger (wood:trees(r),
f.leader.pts) and the hatched strokes (wood:paint(b, r, {...})) on rows 1–2
only. Between rows 3 and 2, lay the floor: wood:floor():roughen(7, 22, seed, 3) in #2a302d→#555c5a down to the foot, hug=false. Use wood:haze(r),
not wood.rows[r].haze, inside color functions: wood.rows builds every tree
(14 s).
Spruces by hand (the older recipe; tree{habit="spruce"} gives a forest spruce with a bare trunk).
tree{habit="spruce"} is a tall forest tree; years=14 gave a lollipop [r4 near]. What
worked is a spruce hand of your own: an axis, then per tier a left and a right branch that
droops and lifts at the tip, longer toward the foot, plus a shorter foreshortened branch
toward you about 70% of the time. The numbers from [r4 near] chunk 7:
- tier = height/22; branch length
L = halfw * (0.12 + 0.88*t^0.85)with a ±15% jitter; droop(0.18 + 0.2*t)*L; tip lift0.08*L; ribbon widthtier*(0.42 + 0.3*t); - the mask is the union of ribbons,
:roughen(max(0.8, tier*0.12), max(3, tier*0.4), seed, 0.5); - fill it with
hand="hatch",round 2, lengths 3 to 9, coverage 3.2, near-black green (#1f2824to#2c3630), angle along the branches (on the young spruce: 2.75 left of the axis, 0.4 right of it); - then draw every branch with a rigger (0.9 to 1.1),
pressure={0.8, 0.05}, ramps={0.05, 0.6}, so the tiers read against the sky.
Place wood-edge spruces with uneven(), tips on a drawn line, heights varied and
overlapping, over one dark interior mass. Even spacing reads as a row of Christmas trees
and an even crest as a clipped hedge. A transparent gray-green glaze over the interior
tones sky holes that read as bright paper at 3200 [r3 near]. Still weak: spires from one
function share a shape, and tiers come out as symmetric chevrons [r4 near]. Vary halfw,
droop and lean per tree.
Oaks and broadleaves.
-
Fuller crowns:
t:foliage{sun=..., clump=0.04, spray=2}gives a broad, dense, rounded crown in place of the clumpy savanna default.clumpis a fraction of tree height, and 0.1 is enormous [r3 green].yearsis hard to predict (80 to 400 gave 6 to 10 limbs); leave it out or try a few values witheasel try[r3 free, r3 green]. -
Preview seeds with
easel tryandshow(t:mask())[r4 green, r3 green]. -
Limbs and trunk first, leaves over them, so the wood shows only in the holes [r3 green].
-
Trunk and thick limbs as filled ribbons, not single strokes (a long stroke from one load runs dry and fades out). For limbs with
l.w[1] >= 3, buildribbon(l.pts, l.w), thenworkin body color (round 2, lengths 4 to 12, coverage 3.5,angle=1.5,clip=). The lit flank isthick * mask(function(x,y) return 1 - thick:at(x - 3.5, y + 1.5) end)in a gray#8a8270[r4 green]. Thin limbs as strokes by width: round 1.8 above width 1, rigger 0.6 below, reload every 5 strokes or under 0.3 fullness. -
Leaves in three hatch layers,
hug=falseso edges thin out, angles from a noise (2.6*turn(x,y), period 9,angle_jitter=0.8): a mid green over the whole crown (round 1.8), then the shadow masses (round 1.6), then the lit masses (round 1.4) [r3 green]. -
Break the silhouette with about 700 small hooked strokes along
crown:rim(5, 1): round 1.4, length 2.5 to 5, a hook ofrandn(0, 0.8),pressure={0.7, 0.05}, light ones where lit and dark in shade [r3 green]. -
Sky back into the holes:
work(leaves:gaps(6) * crown:grow(2) - wood:grow(2), {hand="detail", tool="round 1.4", color=cl}). With the clouds object as the color, the holes match the sky behind [r3 green]. -
Dead snags above the leaves: tapered ribbons (4.2 to 1.4 wide), dark
#4f4a42with a silver lit flank#a29b8d,medium=0.1[r3 green]. -
Roots:
treeroot limbs flare as straight spikes. Bury the foot in grass or snow. For snow, clip the whole tree to a wavy "above the snow line" mask, which reads better than painting snow over a stub [r3 free, r2 winter]. -
What fails: sparse leaves by
stippleread as pollen. Use a few dabs on a random quarter offoliage().clumps[r3 near]. At 3200, hatch dabs inside the crown still read as stippling. Bigger, hooked leaf strokes are the open problem [r3 green]. -
Birch: twigs first, then the white trunk, a gray shadow side, black marks. Place the black patches irregularly with knots where limbs leave; an even ladder of lenticels reads as dashes [r3 near].
-
Field trees as groups (beat "identical balls"): 1–5 trees per group, each crown drawn separately, ~30% tall and narrow, one faint uneven shadow per group, muted olive fading with distance. [loop 1 green]
-
Opening a black wood at its foot (loop 2 near): a low horizontal band of dim, shaded floor (
#323b38→#6b706f) at the wood's foot, near-black trunks (round 3.2) with low boughs (round 1.4) over it, and a thin veil in vertical columns higher up for air between the back trees. Pitfall: pale vertical patches read as ghosts. Paint trunks with pressure rising toward the TOP, or they end in points. -
Breaking a wood-edge comb (loop 2 near): treetops
randn(0, 30)around the drawn line (not ±12), one tree ~55 units above the rest, a few young ones 25–60 lower, crown width 0.18–0.32 of height, some twin spires. Pitfall (critics): symmetric stacked tiers with a white edge on every tier read as a Christmas card; Friedrich's firs are short hatched strokes. [loop 2 near, loop 2 critics] -
Replacing a hand-made wood with
fir_wood{}in an existing log (loop 5 near, +1): reuse the old skyline, give it a wavy foot line and keep the old mask's name (woodm = wood:mask()) so later chunks still run; then drop every chunk that patched the old interior. Snow at a wood's foot without a ledge: the foot outline'sbelow(H)with a noise-varied fade depth (392 + 26*n, ±18), colored with the wood's cool cast shade mixed into the sampled field; snow on the wood only on sun-side strokes of the front row:wood:paint(b, 1, {kind="top", lit={0.62, 1}, every=5}). [loop 5 near]
6. Rocks and stones
Ceiling: stones read as loaves, eggs or stacked masonry; snow on stone reads as blotches or lichen.
Rocks from a drawing: rock{} (use this before building a rock from ellipsoids and cuts).
Draw the silhouette as outline{pts=..., char="broken"} ("firm" for a sure contour).
Mark corners with "c". Draw the main cracks as point lists. Then
r = rock{outline=o, cracks={...}, kind="granite"|"sandstone"|"chalk", sun=..., seed=}.
It infers the planes, lights them and gives masks and fields [rocks_in study,
paintings/lua/rocks_in.lua, paint_rock in chunk 2]:
- Take the color from
r:value()through a five-stop gradient anchored onr:levels(0.03, 0.97). Mix inP.bouncebyr:reflected()andP.corebyr:core(). - Lay the whole mass (filbert 4, coverage 3.2, medium 0.25) and then
r:lit(0.2)stiffer (medium 0.12). Both goangle=r:field("plane"), so the strokes change direction at every plane break. blend(r:shadow(0.3), ...)only. Blending the whole rock gave back the pale smooth loaf.- Stroke every line in
r.seamsonce with a round brush (pressure={0.8, 0.2},clip=r:mask()). Shortdetailstrokes overr:cracks()came out as dotted lines, and the sandstone read as a crate. - Glaze
r:cast()(0.3 coats) andr:contact()(0.35), each times a mask of your panel or ground, because the cast shadow reaches far under a low sun.
What decided the look:
-
Draw the outline lopsided. My first erratic, drawn as a symmetric dome with a crack down the middle, was a loaf with a seam. A high shoulder, a broken back and a crack running off at an angle made it a stone.
-
Draw a sandstone ledge with a flat top and a stepped flank. A domed outline gives a bedded loaf.
-
Under a low sun over snow, give the light a strong bounce from below. Use
sun={from={-1, -0.14}, front=0.3, bounce=0.55, bounce_from={0.3, 1, 0.45}}. With the default bounce the shadow side was the critics' "flat purple half". -
Snow:
r:snow{amount=0.7, depth=3}:blur(2):map(...), painted in masstone. It still shows dark flecks at 1000 px (unsolved). -
An ellipsoid alone is an egg or a loaf. What reads as stone: one mass, turned, roughened at two scales, cut by two or three fracture planes, e.g.
body.ellipsoid(c, r):turn(c, 0.35, 0.08, -0.07) :rough(0.08*R, 0.9*R, 3) -- R = the radius :cut(top, {-0.25, -1, 0.35}, 10, 0.05*R):cut(side, {0.9, -0.35, 0.3}, 11, 0.04*R) :rough(0.017*R, 0.17*R, 5, true) -- fine pitted grain[r4 near]. The first round-3 rough (
0.1*r, 1.4*r) gave eggs, andrough(1.2, 14, s, true)gave cork.rough(0.16*r, 0.7*r)plus a finer one worked [r3 free]. A rounded block fused with a flat ellipsoid on top reads as an erratic [r2 coast]. Bigroundvalues on blocks give pillows, and stacked hard blocks give masonry [r3 near]. -
sizeands:sizetake radii. Two painters' first boulders were twice the size they meant [r4 near, r3 green]. -
Paint from the form: body color from
f:valuethrough a four- or five-stop granite gradient, OKLab mottling withshift, strokes alongf:field("fall")in shadow andf:field("across")on the lit face (filbert 4, lengths 6 to 18, coverage 3.6,clip=the stone) [r4 near, r4 green]. Thenblendso the wet paint fuses into a hard surface. Without the blend, filbert strokes at 3200 looked like a bristly haystack [r3 green]. -
Fissures:
f:edges{turn=0.7, step=3, span=2.5, concave=true} * stone:shrink(3), detail round 1.4 alongf:field("edge"), plus two or three drawn fractures with a round 1.6 andshake=1.2[r4 near]. A fine default span makes pumice. Keep edges to strong turns over a wider span [r2 coast]. Pure-black fissure specks read as pepper [r4 near], so use a dark gray#2e2c2f, not black. -
Lichen: a
worley(period 9) mask gated by a slow noise, stippledwidth=1.4,coverage=1.1,aim=false,fade=0.5, pale gray-green and ochre [r4 near]. Keep it on the sky-facing lit planes. -
Weathering turned camouflage mottle into old stone: dark streaks glazed down from each ledge with a stretched noise, lichen rosettes clustered by worley, pits in the undercut [r3 near].
-
A straight base line makes a rock architecture. Sink the foot in grass, bracken or drifted snow; fallen blocks from polygons read as sugar cubes [r3 near].
7. Snow
Ceiling: snow fields are flat and empty; lit snow under a low sun came out lilac until overruled by hand.
-
Snow on the ground from the view's light, remapped. At an 11° sun, lit flat snow is only 0.37 to 0.49 in
v:at(x,y).shade.value. Probe first, thenmix(blue_gray, warm_white, smoothstep(0.3, 0.5, lit)), graying with distance. Use onlyp.what == "ground". The first pass came out lilac everywhere [r4 near]. -
Snow on the upper faces of a shape (boughs, ledges):
mask(function(x, y) return m:at(x, y) * (1 - m:at(x, y - 2.5)) end), gated by noise, thenstipple(tops, {width=1.5, coverage=2.2, pressure={0.4, 0.8}, drag={1, 0}, aim=false, medium=0.15, fade=0}), heaviest and warmest on the sun side.dry()first [r4 near]. Strokes there made a chevron "rain" pattern. On limbs, drop snow runs shorter than three widths, or they bead [r2 winter]. -
Snow cap on a stone:
f:mask(function(s) return smoothstep(-0.55, -0.8, s.n[2]) end)(normal facing up), broken by noise,:roughen(2, 8, seed, 0.6), filbert 3 in body, color fromf:value[r4 near]. -
Snow drifted against a foot: a soft open
outlinealong the foot, its path shifted down and turned into aribbonof varying width,:roughen(2.5, 10, seed, 1.5). Color it from the snow just below (sample(x, y + 26, 4), lightened a touch), thenblendit [r4 near]. -
Cast shadows on snow:
glaze(vs:cast_shadow{soft=2.2}, {color="#6a7090", coats=0.32}). At 0.5 coats they were too heavy [r4 near]. Filbert strokes on snow look like boards [r2 winter]. A low sun gives a ruler-straight band, so break it with grass laid over it. -
Snow banked against a stone (beat loop 1's drift; loop 2 near +3). Shape ONE continuous bank with a hand-drawn envelope where the wind would pile it (sums of gaussians, e.g.
4 + 13*G(222,48) + 6*G(430,60) + 5*G(590,16), minus where the lee shades it), plus small noise at periods ~95, 19, 6; deep on the windward side, almost gone in the shade. Color it from the snow field itself (sample(x, base+12, 3)), with a slightly darker, cooler line where it tucks under the rock. Pitfall: noise clipped at zero (3 + 26*noise) gives evenly spaced puffs ("cotton balls"). Ceiling: the lip is still fairly even along the front; let the rock meet the snow directly in places. [loop 2 near] -
Contact shade runs over the snow at the stone's foot, not around it. Cutting the drift out of
contact_shadowleaves a lit gap above a floating dark stripe; insteadv:contact_shadow{reach=0.14}:blur(1.5) * -stoneat ~0.22 coats. [loop 2 near] -
Pitfall (critics): a long shadow band across the foreground needs a visible caster and must agree with the other shadows; an unexplained band "contradicts the boulder's own shadow". [loop 2 critics]
-
Pitfall:
roughen()on a soft cast-shadow mask turns its soft edge into hard blocks: vary a soft mask by multiplying, not roughening. Noise stretched along a long ground shadow makes vertical curtains: stretch near horizontal (stretch={0.02, 4}). Thin filbert paint (medium 0.4–0.45) over a rough stone lets the dark grain show through as white lace. [loop 1 near]
8. Grass and foreground particulars
Ceiling: foregrounds are the dullest passages in every round (a barcode of upright dashes, a smooth band with sparse incident); Friedrich's are dark but drawn, every tuft particular.
The foreground is where every round fell shortest of Friedrich. Budget real time for it.
swarddefaults cover everything (69,000 tufts, a uniform lawn) [r3 near]. Give it a noise patch mask asregion,spacing=2.6,thin=0.5. Then tint each tuft from what's under it:g:reload(mix(sample(t.x, t.y, 2), straw, 0.12 + 0.35*rand()*rand()), 0.7)[r3 near]. For winter stubble, cull tufts further with a second noise [r4 near].- A sward starts on a visible line. Add a sparse second sward (
thin=0.75) in front of it, or roughen the region [r3 green]. - The single most effective foreground chunk [r4 green]: about 1,400 long curving
rigger (0.8) blades through the dark foreground band, height
(8 + 34*depth) * rand(0.5, 1.6), a lean from a slow noise plusrandn(0, 0.22), a curl ofrandn(0, 0.25), six colors alternating sunlit tips and dark stalks, reloaded every 7 blades, `pressure={0.35- 0.5*depth, 0}, ramps={0.05, 0.75}`. It turned a barcode of short uprights into a meadow.
- Set each blade down lightly at the root and lift it off (
pressure= {p, 0}, a long release). Pressed at once, blades leave a row of dark beads [r2 mountains]. - Particulars need size and value to show at 1000 px. A 1 px thistle over 1 px grass
of the same value is invisible [r3 green]. Flowers need pressure 0.6 to 1.0 and a 2.4
brush [r3 green]. Transparent mixes (Prussian blue, green earth) vanish on green; push
the thistle toward near-black (
#2f3a24) [r4 green]. - Seed heads: a rigger stalk, then 6 or 7 small
touches down from the tip withdrag={0.2, 1.4}, in pale straw against the dark band [r4 green]. - Bracken: an arching rigger rachis and paired round-brush pinnae that shorten toward the tip, in muted rusts. The first fronds were too small and bright ("orange fern icons"). Lay dark masses under them, then lighter lit fronds over every group, or they read as flat blobs at 3200 [r3 near, r4 near].
- Too even, too dense, too bright. Nearly every first try was all three (lawn, hedge, orange ferns, green moss outline, polka-dot flowers) [r3 near, r3 green]. Cluster particulars with a noise patch field, scale them with depth and make the first try sparser and duller than you think.
9. Figures
Ceiling: figures are stiff, symmetric silhouettes, sometimes cut-out looking at 3200.
- Size figures to the motifs around them. A world-correct 1.75 m man near the viewer was taller than the stones [r3 free].
body_offor a figure from behind worked [r4 green]: a four-point spine (head to hem) with widths about{4.2, 7.5, 7.2, 9.5}*k, two legs, two arms, a hat as a short wide limb,blend=0.5,char="firm". Fill it dark (#2e3136to#23211f) with round 1 in short strokes, then a lit edge fromfig:band(1.2, 0.5)on the sun side only.- Judge figures at 3200:
look --crop ... --scale 3.2. At 1000 px a 50-unit figure is 50 px, and square shoulders, a lost cap or a pale coat don't show [r3 free, r4 green]. - Every later pass must leave the figure alone. A sea veil, its blend and new glints
painted over a figure because the mask never excluded him [r3 free]. Register him as a
layer (
w:layer("figure", mask, spot)) and passbehind={"figure"}, or subtractfigure:grow(1.5)from every later mask. - Birds: small V-strokes, each wing a rigger flick pulled out from the body and lifted at the tip. Heavier brushes gave hearts and beans [r2 winter, r2 mountains].
10. Drawing
- Pencil grades on the Friedrich ground. 2H is invisible at 1000 px on the mid-toned
warm ground, even in a 2x crop;
drawing_mask():area()shows it's there [r4 near, r4 green]. 2B is faint. A 3B firm pass (pressure={0.6, 0.75, 0.7, 0.55}) reads [r4 near]. Draw the search in 2H anyway (it's the right method, and it shows through thin paint at 3200), then restate what you're sure of in 3B. A smaller canvas (canvas{size=...}in mm) makes pencil lines read larger. - Read the points off the picture:
look --grid(and--grid 10on a crop) for coordinates. Keep the point lists in globals (BOULDER,WOODTOP,BROW) so the pencil, the masks and the brush use the same line [r4 near, r4 green]. - Paint into your drawing:
drawing_guide():band(0.7, 1, 0.1)is the drawn line as a continuous mask (not the grainydrawing_mask). show()is the drawing you actually see. Overlay point lists, masks and brush bands (show(pts, {width=8})) before you paint. Round 4 green drew mostly withshow()because the pencil was too faint.easel tryfor everything exploratory (seed searches,v:atandw:spotprintouts, previews). It rolls itself back; round 3's probe chunks had to be undone by hand.outline{}characters:softfor a far wood line (lobe=9to11), a hill brow (lobe=5, amount=0.6) or drift edges (lobe=6to12,amount=1.2to1.4);brokenwith"c"corners for a snapped stump or rock;firmfor figures [r4 near, r4 green]. An open outline's:below(H)is the land under a line. Its lobes point up.
11. Masks
workstrokes overshoot the mask by design.clip=truestops every bristle on the mask's edge [r3 free];edge=(below) carries the passage to it the way a brush does. Usehug=falsewhere an edge should thin out (foliage, drifts, veils).clip=is true or false. A mask there (clip=m:grow(3):blur(2)) has always been read astrue: the strokes clip to the pass's own region, hard, and the grown, softened mask is never used. The reply now says so. For a softer or looser edge useedge=[r7 edges].- Never put a
rect()inside a painted area. It prints ruled edges, even softened. Snow banks, drifts and the stump's snow all showed straight sides [r4 near]. Build fades frommask(function(x, y) return smoothstep(a, b, x) * smoothstep(c, d, y) end)and addhug=false. - Rings make outlines.
(m:grow(n) - m):soften(k)for a contact shadow reads as a cartoon outline [r3 near], and a ring glaze to kill a halo doubled the shadow into a dark outline [r4 near]. Limit the falloff to the base side (y below the foot line) or usev:contact_shadow{}. - Hard masks read as digital. Blur or roughen them before a glaze and lower the coats.
A cloud shadow on a plain came out as ponds, then strips; what worked was
glaze(cs:blur(18), {coats=0.16, pigment="transparent"})[r4 green, r3 green]. - Subtract what's in front, or use depth. Every round lost time to a pass that painted
over an earlier motif (glints over stones and a barrow, a veil over a figure, a range
painted under a knoll) [r3 free, r2 mountains]. With a world,
behind=,visible=and layers do this for you. blendsmears everything inside its region, small details included (bracken turned into orange streaks across a stone's foot) [r4 near]. Blend only the passage you just laid, clipped to it.f:part(x, y)returns 0 off the form, not nil. A test for nil painted nothing, silently [r3 green].
Edges: found, soft and lost [r7 edges]
Decide every edge; vary it along one contour. A stencil (clip=true) makes the edge no
brush makes: one crisp, even line the length of a ridge, the same for every stroke. That is
what Alice and both critics called "a filled selection" in Evening at a Mountain Lake
(measured: the ridge's edge 0.38 units wide all along, 100% crisp, contrast varying 3%,
wandering 0.1 unit off a perfect curve; notes/edges.md). A painter makes an edge
found where a form turns against the light (the peak against the glow, a figure's
lit shoulder), soft along most of a contour and lost where a shape runs into its
neighbor at a close value (a ridge running down into haze, a reflection's lower edge in
the water).
work(m, {..., edge=...})instead ofclip=: each stroke carries its paint up to the region's edge and a little over it, by its own amount, and past the line the brush lifts and its film thins out.edge="soft"for one quality; a function of(x, y)(0 found .. 1 lost) to decide it by the light;edge={found=0.3, soft=0.5, lost=0.2, period=50}for stretches along the contour.ridgeQ = function(x, y) -- found against the glow, lost low in the haze local glow = G(x, SUNX, 150) local low = smoothstep(HZ - 60, HZ - 10, crest(x)) return clamp(0.5 - 0.5*glow + 0.5*low + 0.25*sn(x, y), 0, 1) end work(rangeM, {hand="body", tool="filbert 6", color=rangecol, ..., edge=ridgeQ})lose(m, {where=..., angle=0})after the passage is dry: short strokes of the neighbor's color (dirtied a little with the region's) dragged back across the edge wherewheresays. Level strokes (angle=0) break a reflection's lower edge into the water.- Lay the dead color a few units inside the line (
m:shrink(3)) so the last pass decides the edge; a stencilled dead color shows through a soft edge as a hard one. - Soft edges soften most into wet neighbors (the overrun picks up and mixes); over dry paint they are a thinning film and a broken fringe.
Goes wrong: lose into wet paint with its default lean brush lifts the wet film and
shows what is under it (pale "teeth" along a ridge in the lab); lose over dry paint, or
load more. On a ridge that edge= already carried outward, lose works along the mask's
line, now inside the dark, and leaves gray patches there: use it on edges a pass stencilled
or held found. Large overruns only move the edge out as a staircase of opaque stroke ends;
the fence keeps them short on purpose.
Ceiling: the lab ridge (notes/edges/alice_edges.png) is brushed and varied but still
reads mostly crisp over dry sky (86% of its length found at 3200, from 100%): a truly soft
dark-on-light edge over dry paint needs a blend of the two in the wet or a scumble,
which lose does only roughly. Not yet tried on firs, the figure or grass, or on the
wet engine (r7-paint-wet).
12. Color
-
Aim at what's there.
aim="laid"(default) aims each stroke at the look over what's under it. After a glaze, old colors are wrong: grass loaded with the pre-glaze colors stood out pale. Sample the glazed ground and mix from it [r3 free]. -
Relative color for shadows:
color_over={shift={-0.06, -0.004, -0.017}}(darker, a little bluer) is the ground's own shadow, stroked the way the ground goes [r3 green, r4 green]. Mixing shadows from your own color field instead made them lighter than the real, darker paint [r2 winter]. -
Transparent darks for shadows and glazes: raw umber and bone black,
pigment="transparent". Thin darks with lead white in them go milky and bluish over a darker field [r2 coast]. -
Earth-only palettes for small motifs (
pal:only{"red earth", "raw umber", "bone black"}, or lead white, smalt, ochre and umber for sails and stone). Full-palette mixes show their strongest tube as colored rims where a mark thins [r2 coast], and weathering came out rusty [r2 winter]. -
A color field applies per stroke, sampled every 2 units. Fine structure (drift shading) blurs into blotches unless the field is smooth or stretched along the strokes [r2 winter].
-
Greens: meadows came out too uniformly yellow-green. Friedrich's are cooler and varied, with blue-green darks. Mix the shadow greens toward the sky's blues [r3 green].
-
hand="scumble"is a dry brush. It lays opaque blobs or a lattice of broken strokes, not a veil [r3 near, r4 near]. For "a veil over what's there," usehand="body"withcolor_over=function(x, y, under) return mix(under, c, 0.55) endand thenblend. Scumble works for lit cloud tops and a stone's lit top (coverage 2, medium 0.35) [r4 green]. -
A brush glaze with
color_overis still laid everywhere. Returningunderdoesn't skip the stroke; it drags and flattens texture beneath [r3 green]. Restrict the mask instead. -
Narrow body passes build impasto. Two body passes on a 20-unit trunk reached 1.5 mm of paint. Friedrich's films are thin. Lower
loadandcoverageon small areas [r4 green]. -
Veil that takes color out without flattening texture (loop 1 green +2, light 4→5). Thin glaze strokes, fenced to the area, pulling what's under them 40% toward its own gray plus ~12%
#7b7a5a; for a big lit lawn one glaze#6d6a4cat 0.32 coats. Pitfall: the same veil in heavy long strokes erased the plain and spilled onto motifs: keep veils thin, short-stroked, and cut every motif out. [loop 1 green]
13. Pitfalls that cost the most time
| Pitfall | Fix |
|---|---|
| Paint laid over paint that's still open (translucent rock, fog band, plowed river) | dry() first, or check drying(x, y) [r3 near, r4 near, r4 green] |
| A later pass paints over an earlier motif | Depth layers and behind=, or subtract the motif (grown) from every later mask; crop the motif after every big pass [r3 free] |
clip=<mask> taken for a softer fence (it clips hard to the region itself) |
clip=true or edge= [r7 edges] |
rect() fades and ring masks leave ruled edges and outlines |
smoothstep fades in mask(fn), hug=false, v:contact_shadow [r4 near, r3 near] |
Fixing an early chunk by hand-editing the log (close, sed, 30 to 100 s replay; close once overwrote the edit) |
easel edit N -f, edit N --insert, edit N --drop in the live session [r3 green, r3 free] |
| Probe chunks cluttering the log | easel try [r3 free] |
| Body radii mistaken for full sizes | size and s:size are radii [r4 near, r3 green] |
eye= is absolute, not above the ground: the camera sat inside a knoll |
Make the ground about 0 at the camera [r3 free] |
| Judging detail at 1000 px (figure ruined under a veil, grain in a stipple) | look --crop ... --scale 3.2 on the motif after each pass that touches it [r3 free] |
| A generator's defaults (sward, spruce, oak crown) taken as the answer | Treat each as a first try: thin, cull, vary, restate by hand |
| A chunk that silently painted nothing | Print an area or count at the end of each chunk (print(m:area()), blade counts) [r3 green] |
| The live 3200 crop timing out under load | Retry later, or easel run --crop in the background [r4 near] |
Scratch study sessions write paintings/lua/<name>.lua |
Move study logs to your scratch dir afterward [r3 green] |
-
Never cut motifs out of a veil or glaze with a grown mask (
-(fig:grow(1.5))): the ring between the grown mask and the painted motif keeps the old paint and reads as a glowing halo (loop 2 green: paint score 2 of 10). Use the world's depth instead:glaze(area, {..., behind={"figure", "bodies"}})orvisible="ground"(register hand-painted motifs withw:layer(name, mask, depth)). If you must cut, cut with the motif's exact mask, not a grown one. [loop 2 green, loop 3 critics] -
Hundreds of short broken strokes along an edge read as embossed scribbles at 3200 (loop 2 green's ~900 crown-edge strokes and grass loops); fewer, drawn, varied marks beat many generated ones. [loop 3 critics]
-
Check a proxy's size against the painted motif: proxy/body sizes are radii (
s:sizetakes half-sizes), so a proxy written at full size casts a shadow twice as long and wide; check withw:height(x, y, 1). [loop 3 near] -
A small caster's shadow at a low sun, drawn by hand, when
cast_shadowstarts too far from a small proxy:w:projectthe sun direction from the foot, glaze a mask with half-width6.5 + 7t, edge1 + 9t, fade1 - smoothstep(0.08, 0.62, t)along it. An ellipsoid boulder shades the ground under its own lit belly: subtract below its foot line there. [loop 3 near, +1] -
Removing halos from an existing log (loop 3 green +2): replace every
- X:grow(n)in veil and glaze masks with- X(the exact motif mask); blur a veil's mask first and cut the motifs after the blur, never before.oak:mask()is larger than the painted wood: cut with the painted limbs' own mask. Close a remaining fringe with a small-brush repaint just outside the motif (round 1.6, lengths 2–6, coverage 3, medium 0.25,clip=-M), each stroke's color sampled ~11 units farther out. Check halos at 3200: they can be clean at 1000. [loop 3 green] -
Pitfall: a brush veil with
color_overover a detailed area blurs the detail away. [loop 3 green] -
Tried and rejected (loop 4 near, 0): a distance-graded veil + wet blend over a black wood gave air but smeared it into vertical streaks and lost the trunks. Use
fir_wood{}instead (section 5). -
Glitches at 3200 that are the recipe's, not the engine's (Round 6 glitch census,
notes/glitch.md, sheetnotes/glitch/alice_census.png). Principle: whatever you leave uncovered over a strong underlayer shows at full size as sharp, bright, digital-looking specks and slivers, even when the 1000 px preview reads as a mass. Check atlook --crop ... --scale 3.2and runuv run scripts/glitch.pyon a 3200 crop. Ceiling: these fixes remove the slivers; they don't make the passage good.- Thin long level strokes over the orange Friedrich ground leave slivers of
ground between them (lab 1 water B's open water and sky: the "orangey lines" the
owner called horrible). Fix: a second pass of the same color at a different
stroke length, or a
blend()while open, or tone the ground there first; judgecoverageat 3200, not 1000. [lab 1 water B] - A dense small-brush hatch over a dry pale layer (a dark crown hatched with
round 1.6over a dry sky) leaves pinholes of sky between its ridges. The engine no longer leaves paint on a sliver (glitch P1), but the bare crevices between 200 µm ridges of stiff paint stay open. Fix: lay the crown's darkest mass as one body layer first (dead coloring), then hatch into it; or hatch with more medium. [lab 2 lime P] - A crack left as a masked channel (the lit pass clipped off
rk:cracks()) reads as an even, ruled line of the shadow paint. Fix: paint the crack as a stroke with a pointed round, varying pressure, a light lip on the sunny side, lost halfway (lab 2 rock H does this). [lab 1 rock B] - Thin snow dragged over a dry, ridged rock catches in the hollows and leaves the
ridges' crests bare: at 1000 it reads as snow torn by the grain (as meant), at 3200
as dark outlines round the rock's old strokes. Fix: lay the cap fuller (
load0.9, less medium) or before the rock dries, or accept it only where it reads as grain. [l5_near]
- Thin long level strokes over the orange Friedrich ground leave slivers of
ground between them (lab 1 water B's open water and sky: the "orangey lines" the
owner called horrible). Fix: a second pass of the same color at a different
stroke length, or a
14. Habits of looking
- Look after every chunk (
easel do --look). A third of round 3's chunks were undone; that's normal [r3 free]. - Value and squint at each stage change:
look --mode value,squint. It showed a rock, a sky and a middle floor all at one value. The fix was a painter's fix: darken everything around the rock with transparent glazes toward the bottom and sides [r3 near]. Do it after the lay-in, after the motifs and before the particulars. --driedbefore judging a wet passage's color. Wet paint levels and shifts as it dries.- 3200 crops for handling. 1000 px is for composition and value only. Specks, beads,
dotted edges, the sameness of repeated marks and figure drawing show only at 3200 [r2
mountains, r3 free, r4 near]. Crop each motif at
--scale 3.2after the pass that made it and after any later pass that crosses it. --probefor actual values when a value relation looks off. A "pale" rock that seemed an engine bug was simply lighter than the turf around it [r2 mountains].- A scratch study for a hard motif: three versions side by side on a flat ground, then carried into the painting (the round 3 oak's crown) [r3 green].
- Before the varnish, look for regularity. Every place a round-4 picture looked digital was a place where a loop or mask went down faster than the painter looked: identical trees, barcode grass, ruled hedges, flat shadow bands [r4 green].