What the painters were given

Before you compose: what makes a picture Friedrich's

notes/briefs/friedrich_painter.md · 88 lines · Notes

Given to 4 painters:

Before you compose: what makes a picture Friedrich's

Read this before you draw anything. It is about composition, light and restraint. Materials are in notes/research/friedrich_materials.md. Every claim here has a source in notes/friedrich.md ("What makes a picture Friedrich's", round 7); the key is in brackets. Don't copy a known picture: find your own subject and give it his order.

The principles

  1. Decide the order before the scene. His landscapes "usually adhere to a severe underlying symmetry" and are "relatively empty" [MW]. Start from an axis, a few parallel bands and a simple figure (a triangle, an arch, a curve that opens upward), then clothe it with land. Symmetry holds the whole, and the irregularity lives inside the parts: gnarled branches inside a symmetric frame [MAD cat.29]. A diagonal sweep of land from one corner is the Baroque way. That was Dahl's way, and it is the thing that separated his borrowed dusk and fog from Friedrich's [MW cat.13].

  2. Cut the near from the far. Give a shallow foreground and an unreachable distance, and take away the middle ground a viewer could walk through [RV Rosenblum]. Stack zones parallel to the picture plane. If you need a barrier (a ledge, a wall, a band of growth), let it stop the eye, not lead it in. There is no path into depth and no repoussoir that ushers the viewer along.

  3. Give most of the canvas to the air. In most of his pictures the sky takes more than half [MW cat.8]. Rule the horizon level. Soften it only where mist lies on it [MAD cat.55].

  4. Use one figure or a few, still and on the axis. Seen from behind, doing nothing, never looking up at the sky: straight ahead or down [MW]. Put them where the geometry points: on or near the axis, at the apex, often overlapping the horizon so the head reads against the light [MW cat.7]. A small figure off to the side is staffage, a measure of scale, and that is what his followers did [MW cat.13]. You can have no figure at all.

  5. Paint light, not the sun. The sun has set or sits behind something. The brightest light is a band where the dark land zone meets the light sky zone [MAD cat.29]. Twilight, fog and haze make the distance strange [MW cat.8]. A moon is small and partly veiled [MW cat.9]. One light and one time of day govern the whole picture: no sunset sky over a sunlit foreground [CAR].

  6. Build the sky in bands. Horizontal bands of cloud and color, maybe one wedge of cloud and light across them [MAD cat.74]. The color runs from the brightest at the horizon to deeper color above, without a break [MAD cat.72]. Give the sky your most careful work [MW]. Don't let cloud shapes echo each other or the moon.

  7. Keep water calm and let it echo the sky. His seas are calm [MW cat.7]. The water repeats the sky's colors "more transparently" [MW cat.7] and keeps its own value order: it may darken toward the horizon and lighten again just below it [MAD cat.89]. Mirror the geometry (the horizon as a hinge) rather than copying every form.

  8. Choose one key and a few zones. One dominant tonality, sometimes near monochrome [RV Asvarishch]. Each zone holds its own color rather than all of them blending into one atmosphere [MAD cat.72; MW]. Allow one small accent (a coat, a dress) at most.

  9. Leave out, then leave out more. He drew ships and nets and never painted them [CATS]. A visitor summed up his pictures as a beach, the sea, clouds, a man "that is all" [MW Monrad]. Keep the foreground bare. Carus's plants and flowers are the follower's mistake [MW cat.10]. Every object you keep must be needed. If the picture is not about the light, it is about one object: a ruin, a tree, a cross, a ship [MW cat.6].

  10. Be exact where it matters and let the distance go. Forms against the light are drawn exactly, down to "every needle on the firs" [Ramdohr, in WP-en Tetschen]. Distance is less detailed and dissolves in haze [HH]. That is a decision you make shape by shape, not a blur applied everywhere. He subordinates parts "by correct grouping and by the distribution of light and shadow", not by neglect [WQ].

  11. Let restraint carry the mood. No action, no weather drama, no story, no display of feeling [RV Asvarishch]. One definite feeling rather than all of them mixed [WQ]. Symbols stay few and open, not a rebus [RV Rosenblum].

Check before you paint (the imitator's mistakes)

Source