Before you compose: what makes a picture Friedrich's
Read this before you draw anything. It is about composition, light and restraint.
Materials are in notes/research/friedrich_materials.md. Every claim here has a
source in notes/friedrich.md ("What makes a picture Friedrich's", round 7); the
key is in brackets. Don't copy a known picture: find your own subject and give it
his order.
The principles
-
Decide the order before the scene. His landscapes "usually adhere to a severe underlying symmetry" and are "relatively empty" [MW]. Start from an axis, a few parallel bands and a simple figure (a triangle, an arch, a curve that opens upward), then clothe it with land. Symmetry holds the whole, and the irregularity lives inside the parts: gnarled branches inside a symmetric frame [MAD cat.29]. A diagonal sweep of land from one corner is the Baroque way. That was Dahl's way, and it is the thing that separated his borrowed dusk and fog from Friedrich's [MW cat.13].
-
Cut the near from the far. Give a shallow foreground and an unreachable distance, and take away the middle ground a viewer could walk through [RV Rosenblum]. Stack zones parallel to the picture plane. If you need a barrier (a ledge, a wall, a band of growth), let it stop the eye, not lead it in. There is no path into depth and no repoussoir that ushers the viewer along.
-
Give most of the canvas to the air. In most of his pictures the sky takes more than half [MW cat.8]. Rule the horizon level. Soften it only where mist lies on it [MAD cat.55].
-
Use one figure or a few, still and on the axis. Seen from behind, doing nothing, never looking up at the sky: straight ahead or down [MW]. Put them where the geometry points: on or near the axis, at the apex, often overlapping the horizon so the head reads against the light [MW cat.7]. A small figure off to the side is staffage, a measure of scale, and that is what his followers did [MW cat.13]. You can have no figure at all.
-
Paint light, not the sun. The sun has set or sits behind something. The brightest light is a band where the dark land zone meets the light sky zone [MAD cat.29]. Twilight, fog and haze make the distance strange [MW cat.8]. A moon is small and partly veiled [MW cat.9]. One light and one time of day govern the whole picture: no sunset sky over a sunlit foreground [CAR].
-
Build the sky in bands. Horizontal bands of cloud and color, maybe one wedge of cloud and light across them [MAD cat.74]. The color runs from the brightest at the horizon to deeper color above, without a break [MAD cat.72]. Give the sky your most careful work [MW]. Don't let cloud shapes echo each other or the moon.
-
Keep water calm and let it echo the sky. His seas are calm [MW cat.7]. The water repeats the sky's colors "more transparently" [MW cat.7] and keeps its own value order: it may darken toward the horizon and lighten again just below it [MAD cat.89]. Mirror the geometry (the horizon as a hinge) rather than copying every form.
-
Choose one key and a few zones. One dominant tonality, sometimes near monochrome [RV Asvarishch]. Each zone holds its own color rather than all of them blending into one atmosphere [MAD cat.72; MW]. Allow one small accent (a coat, a dress) at most.
-
Leave out, then leave out more. He drew ships and nets and never painted them [CATS]. A visitor summed up his pictures as a beach, the sea, clouds, a man "that is all" [MW Monrad]. Keep the foreground bare. Carus's plants and flowers are the follower's mistake [MW cat.10]. Every object you keep must be needed. If the picture is not about the light, it is about one object: a ruin, a tree, a cross, a ship [MW cat.6].
-
Be exact where it matters and let the distance go. Forms against the light are drawn exactly, down to "every needle on the firs" [Ramdohr, in WP-en Tetschen]. Distance is less detailed and dissolves in haze [HH]. That is a decision you make shape by shape, not a blur applied everywhere. He subordinates parts "by correct grouping and by the distribution of light and shadow", not by neglect [WQ].
-
Let restraint carry the mood. No action, no weather drama, no story, no display of feeling [RV Asvarishch]. One definite feeling rather than all of them mixed [WQ]. Symbols stay few and open, not a rebus [RV Rosenblum].
Check before you paint (the imitator's mistakes)
- Is there an axis, and does the main thing sit on it or answer to it?
- Can the eye walk from the front edge to the horizon? Then cut the middle.
- Count the kinds of things. The Monk has four: monk, shore, sea and sky [WP-de Mönch]. As a rule of thumb (mine), more than five and it drifts toward a follower's picture.
- Is the figure small, at the side, looking up or doing something? Fix it or drop it.
- Is the sun's disk visible? Is the moon bright, bare and centered? Is the sky dramatic? Are the waves breaking?
- Is the light one light at one hour over the whole picture?
- Did any cloud, tree or wave come from a formula, the same shape repeated? Carus called that "the handy cursive script" of landscape [CAR].
- Is this the Monk again? That picture "stands alone" in his work [RAD]. Most of his pictures are ordered, symmetric and hold one object of contemplation.