What the painters were given

Caspar David Friedrich: painting materials and technique

notes/research/friedrich_materials.md · 131 lines · Research

Given to 6 painters:

Caspar David Friedrich: painting materials and technique

Sourced technical report for a physical paint simulator. Every claim cites a source key; full URLs are in the "Sources" list at the end. "Uncertain" marks claims that are unverified, disputed or taken from a single object.

Bottom line

Friedrich painted in oil on fine, plain-weave linen that he bought already primed. The grounds had two to four thin layers: a warm lower layer (red or ocher) under a light, lead-white-rich top layer [KÖR p.284; CATS p.127]. Over a precise graphite or ink underdrawing he laid a very thin underpainting, then only one or two very thin paint layers [SMB-proj; CATS p.127]. He used few pigments. Before about 1820 his key blue was smalt, a semi-transparent cobalt glass. After that he used cobalt blue and chrome yellow [ALF pp.341, 348–349]. His smooth gradations come from stippling and from paint pooling in the fine texture of the ground, not from thick blending [CATS p.127; NG p.56]. No accessible source gives numeric thread counts or paint-film thicknesses in microns for his paintings. The simulator values below for those are labeled proxies or assumptions.

Terms used below. Ground/priming: the preparatory layers between canvas and paint. Cross-section: a microscopic sample cut through all layers. IRR (infrared reflectography): imaging that shows carbon-based drawing under paint. XRF (X-ray fluorescence): elemental analysis. Glaze: a transparent paint layer. Impasto: thick, raised paint. Lining: gluing a second canvas to the back. Craquelure: the network of cracks in paint or varnish.

1. Supports

2. Grounds (preparation layers)

3. Underdrawing

4. Pigments

Pigment Evidence Notes
Lead white Monk/Abbey [CATS p.127]; Winter Landscape snow [NG pp.51, 56] The main white; used in grounds too
Smalt (cobalt potash glass) Monk/Abbey [CATS p.127]; Winter Landscape [NG p.56]; Two Men by the Sea 1817 [ALF] Several grades from pale gray to deep blue, used alone or with lead white [NG p.56]. Average Co about 3 wt% [NPJ25]. Chosen "on account of its semi-transparent property" [CATS p.127]
Ochers and earths (goethite, hematite) [ALF p.348]; [CATS p.127] Yellow and red earths
Vermilion/cinnabar Abbey sky layer [NPJ25]; violet sky layer of The Cross in the Mountains (1807/08) [KÖR fig. 6] Small admixture in pinks and violets
Red iron oxide Pale mauve sky of Winter Landscape [NG p.56] A few particles
Bone black Grass in Winter Landscape [NG p.56]
Naples yellow Grass in Winter Landscape [NG p.56] Disputed: XRF found no antimony in the areas it tested [ALF p.349]
Prussian blue "Possibly" in Winter Landscape grass [NG p.56]; cape in Man and Woman Contemplating the Moon (1818/24), inferred from K and Fe [ALF Table 2]
Cobalt blue Paintings from 1818/24 on [ALF]; "almost entirely replaced smalt… after about 1820" [NG p.56]
Chrome yellow (lead chromate) 1817 and 1818/24 [ALF] Cadmium yellow in the 1817 painting is probably a later retouching [ALF p.349]
Green pigments "a few… green" pigments [CATS p.127] Not identified. Green earth is unconfirmed
Copper blues No copper detected, which excludes azurite in the areas tested [ALF p.348] Natural or synthetic ultramarine was not reported

5. Binding media and additives

6. Layer structure and application

7. Varnish

8. Condition and aging

Implications for a simulator

Values are sourced (S), proxy from contemporaries or generic studies (P) or assumption needing tuning (A).

Parameter Value Basis
Weave Plain (tabby) linen, handwoven S [KÖR p.283]; thread irregularity A
Thread density 10–16 threads/cm, so 0.63–1.0 mm spacing. Split early about 11–13/cm, late about 14–16/cm P [CATS-E]; split A; "finer late" is S [KÖR p.283]
Weave relief at surface Low: lower grounds level the weave S [KÖR p.284]
Ground stack (early, Berlin type) Bright red, then 2 × light brown; top layer with fine roller-like texture S [CATS p.127]
Ground stack (typical Dresden) 1–3 ocher/red-earth/chalk/barite layers plus a patchy lead-white top S [KÖR p.284]
Ground texture Top-layer brush striations, directional, visible through paint; occasional scratches S [KÖR p.284]
Ground thickness 150–300 µm total P [NPJ24 modeling range], unverified for Friedrich
Underdrawing Graphite/chalk lines, 2 passes, ruled straights. Keep it visible under thin paint (early) and covered (late) S [CATS; ART]
Paint layers 1–2 layers plus a very thin underpainting S [SMB-proj; NG p.56]
Paint film thickness 5–20 µm per layer in skies; thicker only in highlights and snow A (no measured value found)
Texture pooling Pigment fills ground valleys and thins on peaks, giving dotted, strokeless gradients S [CATS p.127]
Smalt layer optics Low hiding power; use several particle-size grades, with coarse particles visible as specks S [CATS; NG p.56; HH]
Opaque elements Lead-white snow and highlights S [NG pp.51, 56]
Transparent/semi-transparent Smalt skies and mist; early "thin transparent layers"; ground and underdrawing show through S [CATS p.127; NG p.49; HH; KÖR p.284]
Brush modes Stipple (skies/mist), short hatch (conifers), fine upward flick (grass, applied last), rare light impasto S [NG pp.50, 56]
Palette pre-1820 Lead white, smalt, yellow/red ocher, vermilion, bone black, umber (grounds); Naples yellow and Prussian blue uncertain S [NG; ALF; NPJ25]
Palette post-1820 Add cobalt blue and chrome yellow; smalt declines S [ALF; NG p.56]
Original varnish Very thin egg-white film, then mastic S [KÖR p.283]
Aged varnish Up to 7 yellowed layers; microcracked varnish scatters light S [SMB-blog]
Smalt aging Blue fades toward gray/brown; binder shows through S [NPJ25; HH]
Crack spacing / island size Center: 2–6 mm isotropic network (A). Corners: cracks perpendicular to the diagonal, 6 ± 3 mm spacing, within 5–10% of the diagonal (P) [NPJ24]
Abrasion Micro-losses exposing ground on peaks of texture S [SMB-blog]; peak location A

Sources

Source