Friedrich's hand: read before painting
One page on how he worked, in order, and where the irregularity in his
surfaces comes from. Principles, not recipes. Sources and details:
notes/research/friedrich_process.md (keys in brackets refer to it).
How he worked, in order
- Studies from nature, carried home. Pencil studies of single trees, rocks and ranges, with notes on them: "in the distance," a ground line, the horizon, ranges numbered front to back for their aerial perspective later [KH]. The picture itself was invented whole in his head [NG p.49], and its parts were taken from the studies almost unchanged, enlarged and traced onto the canvas [MOST-abs; KÖR fig.8].
- A bare room, one light from above. Nothing on the walls but rulers; the paints kept in the next room [NG; WP-KERSTING-EN]. Kersting shows him seated with his arm on a maulstick, or standing, leaning on a chair back: close, small, deliberate work.
- A bought ground, tone chosen for the light. Warm under white, or reddish ocher as the mid-tone of a moonlit picture. Its brush striations and even a scratch stayed visible; he let them [KÖR p.284].
- Draw everything. Faint chalk or pencil, then the whole picture "properly and definitely" in pen and ink, grass and leaves included; straights ruled; symmetry guides rubbed off before paint [NG pp.49, 58]. No part is drawn less carefully because it matters less [CATS p.132].
- A thin brown lay-in, like a sepia wash. Values first, in one color [NG p.49; KÖR fig.1].
- One or two thin layers of color over it, glazes over the light ground; body color only in snow, lights and last touches [NG pp.51, 56]. He darkened with blue [MÄD]. Greens in up to four layers of different greens [MÄD].
- Each passage in its own hand. Skies, mist and far hills stippled, so thin that the paint gathers in the ground's pits and no stroke shows [NG p.56; CATS p.127]. Firs in short hatching. Near snow slightly pastose. Ice dry-brushed. Ground left bare in places [HH].
- Leave things out. He drew ships, nets, a well and a walking stick, and painted none of them [CATS; NG; WP-ZM]. He seldom added what wasn't drawn [ART].
- In states, over months. The Monk's sky was seen gray and heavy, then pure and calm, then with a moon and morning star; the final sky was painted just before shipping. The whole picture had first been laid in dark blue [WP-Monk; SMB-blog]. Stop, let it dry, look, repaint what is wrong.
- Particulars last, in opaque paint: grass blade by blade in fine upturned or straight strokes over the finished ground, gulls placed on the finished sky, the moon in white [NG p.56; CATS p.130; WP-ZM].
Where the irregularity comes from
Not from noise added at the end. It is layered in the matter:
- The ground: knife waves under brush striations under thin paint; a patchy white; a scratch.
- The drawing: two passes, lines broken where the pen skipped over the ground, beads of ink where it lifted, ghosts of guides rubbed away, lines that "shimmer through" [NG p.58; CATS p.130].
- The paint: thin paint pooled into dots; coarse smalt splinters as blue specks; a few pigments mixed by hand, never the same twice; thickness that changes from passage to passage.
- The edges: at a boundary two colors may not even touch; the ground shows between them, with dots of the drawing left in the gap [HH].
- The changes: a repainted sky, a turned figure, overpainted ships.
- Time: cracks, yellowed and crazed varnish, faded smalt, abrasion from old cleanings [SMB-blog; HH].
Principles
- Precise in drawing, uneven in matter. Copies fail by being even, fast and vague: the Dortmund copy has no underdrawing, "a more even paint surface" and "rapidly applied" passages [NG p.50]. Our renders fail the same way.
- A few mixed piles, never a formula. His color came from a spare palette and the knife. A smooth color function across the sky is the opposite of his method (Alice: "maybe a little too perfect").
- Detail is not graded by importance, but by distance. Near things are drawn blade by blade; far things are "single delicate brushstrokes" the eye assembles [HH].
- Lost edges by stipple and pooling, found edges by drawing and the last opaque touch. Decide each one; don't soften everything.
- Look at two distances. Close up his pictures read as drawing; from across the room, as light [WP-Tetschen]. Check both before you stop.